4 Charles Prime Rib feels like stumbling upon a delicious secret that somehow the entire city already knows about. This intimate supper club-style space has mastered the dark, moody ambiance that makes you want to settle in for hours with a martini in hand.

Their prime rib is, unsurprisingly, the star of the show – a gloriously tender, perfectly pink slab of beef that arrives with all the traditional accompaniments. But don’t overlook their burger, which has developed something of a cult following among NYC food enthusiasts. It’s a juicy, decadent masterpiece topped with American cheese and bacon that somehow manages to outshine many dedicated burger joints in the city.

The vibe here strikes that elusive balance between special occasion worthy and comfortably unpretentious. Reservations are notoriously tough to snag (plan weeks ahead), but that’s part of what makes finally sliding into one of those leather booths feel like such an achievement.

The attentive service, impressive wine selection, and those heavenly sides – especially the crispy hash browns – round out an experience that embodies classic New York dining at its finest.