Lillie’s Times Square manages to be one of those rare treasures in the heart of tourist central – a place with genuine character and charm that doesn’t feel like a tourist trap. This Victorian-style pub tucked away on West 49th Street offers a welcome respite from the neon chaos just steps away.

What makes Lillie’s truly special is the incredible atmosphere. The moment you walk in, you’re transported to another era with its ornate mahogany bar, antique furnishings, and stained glass details that were actually imported from a Belfast mansion. It’s like drinking in a museum, but one where you can relax and be comfortable. The intricate woodwork alone is worth visiting for – every corner reveals some new carved detail or vintage curiosity.

The food is solid pub fare with some Irish influences – their shepherd’s pie and fish and chips hit the spot, especially paired with a perfectly poured Guinness or one of their creative cocktails. While it’s not a culinary destination, the food exceeds expectations for a Times Square adjacent establishment.

What’s most compelling about Lillie’s is how it offers a genuine oasis of character and calm in one of Manhattan’s most frantic neighborhoods. It’s equally perfect for a pre-theater drink, a casual lunch, or showing out-of-town visitors that Times Square can actually be charming when you know where to go.